Lidl given go-head for Carndonagh store after failed appeal by local retailer

Planning permission has been given for a Lidl store in Carndonagh more than two years after the application was made and following an appeal to An Bord Pleanála by the owner of the town’s Supervalu

Permission has been given for a Lidl supermarket in Carndonagh after an appeal by the owner of the town’s Supervalu against a grant of planning.

An Bord Pleanála has granted planning more than two years after the application by the German discount retailer to build a 2,209 square metre store on the R238  at Station Road, around 200 metres from the town centre.

Lidl has eight stores in Donegal, including one in Buncrana and applied to build one in Carndonagh in October 2021. The grant of permission to Lidl Ireland GmBH in May 2022 for a Carndonagh store by Donegal County Council was appealed to An Bord Pleanála by Gerry Doherty of Donagh Traders Ltd, which runs Supervalu in Carndonagh.

The appeal argued that the scale and location of the proposal represent a significant threat to the vitality and visibility of Carndonagh town centre, would saturate the existing convenience retail market and have a detrimental impact on smaller retail stores within the town centre. It stated that the development of a multinational discount store would not support local Irish business and “would result in a cumulative impact on the vitality, viability and primacy of Carndonagh town centre and the demise of local established retailers in the area”. 

The appeal also raised concern about existing traffic congestion on the road network in the vicinity of the site and that the development would attract traffic from a wide catchment, resulting in increased traffic congestion within the town. 

In its response to the appeal, Lidl stated that 18% of shoppers using the Lidl in Buncrana come from the Carndonagh catchment area and that the provision of additional retail floorspace within the town would strengthen the draw of Carndonagh and bring shoppers back into the town. 

An Bord Pleanála senior planning inspector Stephanie Farrington found that the principle of the development was acceptable and in accordance with the county council’s strategy to promote a diversity of retail types. 

She said the development would bring an expansion of the retail offer of the town that “would claw back expenditure loss from the catchment area and reduce unsustainable travel patterns”.

The diversification of the retail offer, and associated expansion of the consumer base of the town, could bring potential for spin-off benefits for existing retailers within the town centre, she said.

The board granted planning permission with 20 conditions after finding that the development would not seriously injure the amenities of the area or of property in the vicinity, and would be acceptable in terms of traffic safety and convenience. 

Under the conditions, an archaeological appraisal of the site must be carried out and its results submitted to Donegal County Council before work begins. The Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage had pointed out that given the scale, extent and location of the development it is possible for archaeological remains to be present. 

The conditions also include that a minimum of 10% of the planned 103 car parking spaces should be provided with electric vehicle charging points.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice